Dinner at Umai

When I reviewed Umai at the end of March, I gave it two stars, based mainly on the fact that service was amateurish and erratic, that it took eons to get dishes out of the small, open hijiki seaweed salad kitchen and that much about the French-Japanese fusion restaurant seemed provisional. The food, however, was close to excellent.

Last night’s meal proved that service is much better — well-known waiter Patrick McNamara, formerly of Wally Joe, now presides at Umai — the food still takes a while to get to the table but not hours, and the food itself is better than ever. In fact, throughout our dinner, there wasn’t a single misstep. Presentations are artful, beautifully detailed, without being precious or pretentious; flavors are married in series of often playful comparisons and contrasts, the primary emphasis being on purity and intensity. Sushi and sashimi are now available at Umai, but we stuck with the regular menu.

Dinner began with a tasty tuna salad-kimchi amuse-bouche and continued with appetizers of black mussels and the fish Grenobloise. The mussels are flash roasted and then steamed in and served in a kimchi-miso broth and accompanied by thin triangles of toasted bread. This is a great mussels preparations. The mussels are good size and deeply flavorful, as is the broth, which brings an earthy exotic flavor. The Grenobloise is an unusual dish for a restaurant that employs so many Japanese themes and ingredients; this preparation is pure French bistro, two small filets of (in this case) flounder, crusted with panko crumbs and perfecty fried, served on dense, glossy mashed potatoes with a caper-butter sauce.

LL ordered the roasted hijiki seaweed salad, a dish of striking intensity and power. As you can see in the photograph above (which she took), the salad is also beautiful to look at, flecked with sesame seeds, topped with thin lemon slices and adorned with a hem of English peas. I had the ’ginger-sweet soup du jour, a generous portion of ginger and sweet potato soup (no cream) with exquisite balance between the ginger and the sweet potato. (That’s the other image, which I took.)

Since we were drinking red wine (the Hewitson “Miss Harry” 2005), we chose red meat entrees. LL had the “Drunken Duck,” slices of medium rare duck breast that had been marinated for 48 hours and then seared. These are served on a bed of creamed potatoes with steamed choi sum (in the bok choi family) and the dark mahogany “drunken duck” sauce. I’ll unlimber the word “intensity” again at this moment to say that the duck is one of the most emphatically rich, deeply flavorful and intense dishes, I mean sublimely delicious, I have ever encountered, and we made little inroad, though we took home what we couldn’t eat.

Almost that intense is the sirloin strip encrusted with guajillo (a chile pepper common to Mexico) and chickory coffee, grilled to the requested medium rare — actual medium rare — and served with a tasty and exotic “sour” fried rice and a Japanese curry veal au jus. Lord have mercy! We took a lot of that home too.

McNamara convinced us to try one dessert, the “homemade pie du jour,” last night being an apple and apricot tart that was almost more savory than sweet.

When people talk about bargain dining, Umai should be at the top of the list. Appetizers are $7 to $13, entrees are $17 to $20. The short but well-chosen wine list is equally cost-conscious, the white wines ranging from $20 to $29, the reds from $16 to $35.

The restaurant still feels a bit provisional in furnishings and comfort-level — it’s cold in fall and winter — but service is thoughtfully Old School and the food, as I think I’ve indicated here, is superb.

Umai is at 2015 Madison. It’s open for lunch Wednesday through Friday, dinner Wednesday through Saturday and for Sunday brunch. Call 405-4241.

This post has:
9 comment.
Posted in:
Eating adventures
Share this post:
Email This Post Share on Facebook

9

Responses to “Dinner at Umai”

Carole H

A restaurant worthy of a “Lord have mercy” from Fredric! I hope the people at Umai realize how close to Nirvana they have arrived! Now I have a question - how do you decide which restaurants to review on the blog and which ones to review in the Friday Playbook? I read and enjoy both, of course, but I’m sure a lot of others do not. Are you trying to keep the “good stuff” among the foodies?! If so, we appreciate it - I’m there for the Grenobloise!

Chris

I am glad the hours were posted. I have tried several times during lunch and dinner to go and it is always closed………….hopefully I can catch them during hours now.

LL

This post may tell you more about the way your restaurant critic lives than you want to know. We are standing in the kitchen eating out of foam take-out boxes from Umai. It wasn’t supposed to be this way–we have a hunk of salmon, etc., but, since we arrive home famished, our hors d’oeuvres are sometimes last night’s take home. Thus. We opened the steak and duck and a bottle of
Gainey merlot, meaning of course to get on with the salmon. Ah well, intention…the leftovers from Umai are so so so? seductive that we gave up and gave in and there we go. Yeah, they’re cold. Doesn’t matter. The slightly sour fried rice with the deeply fragrant and earthy steak is so good, I’ll regret when it’s gone (1.6 minutes) and the slightly sweet drunken duck with the ethereal mashies, well… Ken Lumpkin’s exquisite presentations are not observed here, but the tastes don’t suffer. The salmon will keep.

melissa

Umai is one of the few places in town that serve gourmet vegetarian. If that is your leaning ask (generally not on the menu) and you will be blown away. You won’t find the obligatory grilled portabello or eggplant here.

Fredric Koeppel

First, everything LL says is true. As always.
Second, Carole H, since I reviewed Umai in the Playbook at the end of March, this blog post is just in the way of going back and checking on the place, a function that the blog allows us to do easily. And as we get toward the end of the year, Jennifer and I like to go back to some of the places we have reviewed favorably or not, to make sure they’re still up to form or if they have improved.

Michael

Speaking of restaurants to return to, Majestic Grille has a new, completely revamped wine list. Great selections & very good prices plus a selection of magnums! We went there for dinner last Sunday to try out their “Sunday Suppers” & it was excellent. It’s $60 for 4 people, a total deal. We had winter green salad with feta & red wine vinaigrette, roast pork with braised apples & cider, smashed carrots & parsnips, roasted garlic new potatoes & the most supple, tasty, spicy warm apple cake I’ve ever had.

Carole H

Thanks for clearing that up, Fredric. And LL, it is so refreshing to hear you say you take food home. I know people who are embarrassed to do that, but I almost always bring home what I’m too full to eat in a restaurant. I have prime rib leftovers from last night’s dinner at The Butcher Shop waiting for me for dinner tonight. I ordered it medium rare on purpose & ate the parts that were more done so the leftovers would still be at least medium for round two. That way I can enjoy it twice rather than stuffing myself senseless & then being mad that I didn’t save some for later. I certainly didn’t need 14 ounces of prime rib at one sitting, & that was the smallest cut on the menu.

Todd

I too find that Majestic is a great bargain. It’s not among the best restaurant in town, but its a great meal in a beautiful atmosphere at a very inexpensive price. You can eat there for not much more than you would spend at Chili’s, but you get a near-upscale experience. It’s a great place to take a group of people when you’re picking up the tab, because suburbanites are always impressed with the beautiful dining room, are happy with the food and service, and you can pay the bill without thinking “why did I offer to do this?”.

FIG

Loved Umai. The sushi I had there was probably the freshest tasting fish in town. Way better than any of the Sekesuis.

Leave a Reply